I’m in favor of discrimination. But let me make this clear. I am not in favor of racial discrimination, or gender discrimination, or age discrimination. I don’t believe that anyone’s religion makes him/her better or worse than anyone else, and I do believe that gays should have every right that straights have. I’m a pretty equal opportunity guy except for two things:
1. I don’t think you should tolerate poor performance from your employees.
2. I don’t think you should tolerate poor behavior from your customers.
On a scale of 1-10, how would you rate each of your employees in terms of their performance? This is a purely subjective measure, but it’s a perfectly valid measure too. If you rate someone a nine, I think you’re saying that you’re almost completely satisfied with their performance—and whatever small things could be improved are pretty far down on your priority list. If you rate someone a six, I think you’re saying that you’re only borderline satisfied with their performance—and the things that need to be improved should be pretty high on your priority list. A six or lower has to be draining the overall performance of your company, right? Does it make any sense not to do something about that?
OK, what do you do? Not knowing the specific problems, I can only give you a general answer, but the general solution to your problem is still pretty clear. First, consider improving performance through training. Second, consider improving performance through management and motivation. Third, if neither of those works, consider improving performance through replacement.
If you can’t improve the performance of the individual, your only sensible option is to replace the individual—and that’s especially true considering the current unemployment rate. There are highly talented people looking for jobs right now. If they’re more talented—or more dependable, or more productive, or more likely to help you make a profit—than the people you have working for you right now, you should definitely consider making changes.
But read this at least twice before you make the decision to terminate a poor performer.
First, it is your responsibility to make sure that your employees have the training they need to do their jobs. If poor performance is the result of poor training, that’s your fault, not the employee’s. Beyond that, you have a responsibility to provide effective management and motivation. If poor performance is the result of poor management, that’s your fault too. And if that’s the case, you can replace every one of your employees, but that probably won’t solve your problem.
On the same scale of 1-10, how would you rate each of your top, say, 25 customers? Again, this is a purely subjective measure, but a perfectly valid measure too. If you rate a customer a nine, I think you’re saying that you’re almost completely satisfied with their contribution to both your top line and your bottom line. If you rate someone a six, I think you’re saying that they’re more trouble than they’re worth. Again, does it make any sense not to do something about that?
This is not necessarily a call to fire that customer, although it may come to that. Plan A, though, should be to try to change the customer’s poor behavior. I’ve been out on a lot of customer calls that started with, “Thank you for your business,” and then continued with, “We’d like to do even more business with you,” and then continued with, “But we’ve noticed that things don’t always go smoothly when we do business together, and we suspect you’ve noticed that too. Can we talk about smoothing out some of the rough edges?”
That usually allows for a frank discussion of the stress factors, and it often results in changed behavior. As I’ve explained in seminars, sometimes they are bad customers because they are jerks, which means you’ll probably have to fire them. But sometimes, they’re bad customers because they’re civilians. That’s my term for people who don’t have professional knowledge of our industry. So provide them with some of that knowledge. You might be surprised at how often this works.